V#2 er orginalen, riktignok noe beskåret.

Synes v#2 står godt på egen hånd.

v#1 ble litt for maleriaktig, så jeg likte v#2 best.. men syns kanskje du skulle hatt de samme fargene i v#2 også. tror det hadde gjort seg...!?

Flot stemningsmotiv.

Hei...

Dette var utrolig flott. stemningen blir litt trollsk..

jms

Versjon 2 var kjempefin! Mystisk, drømmende stemning...

Versjon 2 var kjempefin! Mystisk, drømmende stemning...

That’s interesting - most people seem to prefer V2 - as I do, but it also means that the effect used in the first version does obviously not enhance the subjects ''utråling'' - or to use a stronger term - it is contra-productive towards the potential expression of the image.

I'm only mentioning this under this image because it is to my mind a good example for something, I believe, can be observed elative often - the balance of what I would call the original motivation of understanding and transferring the spotted subject into an image.

When comparing the two images, in my opinion you have without any doubt succeeded to keep, communicate something in your image - and weakened it in the manipulated version.

Please take this as one individual opinion - and not a general statement about your image - your perception might react on the V1 stronger, better or more direct - it was just too obvious when reading through the comments.